Elections

Ignore the Seattle Times editorial board and vote YES on I‑1631 for a clean energy future

Edi­tor’s Note: This morn­ing, The Seat­tle Times announced its oppo­si­tion to Ini­tia­tive 1631, the ground­break­ing mea­sure to put a price on pol­lu­tion and use the pro­ceeds to fund a just and respon­si­ble tran­si­tion to a clean ener­gy econ­o­my. Found­ing NPI board­mem­ber Gael Tar­leton had this to say in response.

The Seat­tle Times has reporters who are some of the nation’s best jour­nal­ists inves­ti­gat­ing the scale and impacts of cli­mate change.

I wish that the edi­to­r­i­al board had weighed the excep­tion­al work of their own inde­pen­dent jour­nal­ists to make their endorse­ment rec­om­men­da­tion on Ini­tia­tive 1631. Instead, the board rec­om­mends a “no” vote. It argues that the mea­sure fails the “account­abil­i­ty” test because an “un-elect­ed board appoint­ed by the Gov­er­nor would pro­pose” how to spend the $1 billion+/year in pol­lu­tion fees.

Here’s the deal: this nation, state, and our local gov­ern­ments changed the rules forty plus years ago about giv­ing pub­lic mon­ey to unelect­ed boards to spend.

It’s how we run gov­ern­ment today. Elect­ed offi­cials in Con­gress, state leg­is­la­tures, and city and coun­ty coun­cils and com­mis­sions send bil­lions of dol­lars to non­prof­it orga­ni­za­tions. Those non­prof­its have unelect­ed boards. They spend pub­lic mon­ey on health, hous­ing, edu­ca­tion, and oth­er pub­lic ser­vices that used to be pro­vid­ed exclu­sive­ly by the pub­lic sec­tor, specif­i­cal­ly by pub­lic agencies.

The Seat­tle Times makes a real­ly lame argu­ment that our bal­lot mea­sure to com­bat cli­mate change has an “unelect­ed board” spend­ing the pub­lic’s money.

No, it does­n’t. The board that I‑1631 would cre­ate pro­pos­es projects to the gov­er­nor. The state leg­is­la­ture appro­pri­ates the mon­ey. Just like always.

The pow­er of the purse rests with the elect­ed Legislature.

Don’t fall for this false argu­ment that “unelect­ed boards” should­n’t be spend­ing your mon­ey. Non­prof­it orga­ni­za­tions with unelect­ed boards have been spend­ing your mon­ey for decades with very min­i­mal account­abil­i­ty to any elect­ed body.

This argu­ment is spe­cious — the edi­to­r­i­al board rais­es an issue that is periph­er­al to the real impact of this bal­lot measure.

The entire edi­to­r­i­al reads like a “busi­ness as usu­al is good enough” trea­tise. It implies there is no urgency to tack­le the cli­mate cri­sis and its many ramifications.

It makes me wish I had spent my entire endorse­ment inter­view mak­ing the case for the edi­to­r­i­al board to rec­om­mend a “Yes on I‑1631.”

Instead, I am mak­ing my case to the voters.

Please vote YES on I‑1631 to help our state urgent­ly tack­le cli­mate change to pro­tect our peo­ple and every com­mu­ni­ty, rur­al and urban, farms and forests, fish and orcas, as we con­front the great­est threat to our econ­o­my and way of life.

Please vote yes to doing what we can, right now, for the next decade, to pro­tect future gen­er­a­tions. It’s time to sprint.

Gael Tarleton

Gael Tarleton is an NPI Advisory Councilmember and former Washington State Representative who led two Russian subsidiaries during the 1990s and lserved as a senior defense intelligence analyst on Soviet strategic nuclear programs at the U.S. Defense Intelligence Agency from 1981-1990. She served on NPI's board from its inception through 2021.

Recent Posts

Get an operator’s view of every new East Link / Line 2 light rail station

View a collection of photographs that give a sense of what the new Eastside stations…

2 days ago

What’s it like to ride East Link light rail? In a word: Incredible!

Read NPI's recap of the East Link preview ride on April 25th, 2024, which gave…

3 days ago

Most voters in the Pacific Northwest want Democratic representation in the U.S. House, NPI tri-state poll finds

52% of 1,012 Washington, Oregon, and Idaho voters surveyed by Civiqs earlier this month for…

3 days ago

President Joe Biden is on track for victory in Washington and Oregon this fall, while Donald Trump has a big lead in Idaho

Unsurprisingly, the Democratic Party's presumptive 2024 nominee will likely have the support of a majority…

4 days ago

U.S. Senate sends bipartisan lethal aid appropriations bill to President Joe Biden

The bill will provide tens of billions of dollars in security assistance to Ukraine, Israel,…

5 days ago

Corporate backers of Mark Mullet launch an independent expenditure to boost his flagging campaign

Although the ad looks at first glance like it was created by Mullet's campaign, it…

5 days ago